Atanu Dey On India's Development

Karan Thapar is Clever

Karan Thapar is a columnist at Hindustan Times. In a Dec 29th piece titled “Modification of Politics,” I came across one of the most clever euphemisms for assassination. If you thought his ‘modification’ in the title of his piece was oh-so-clever, wait till you read how he phrases Modi’s murder. He calls it “the sudden removal of Modi”.

The context is that he is concerned about the growth of “moditva” and speculates that regional political parties will be forced to side with “Modi or Sonia, in the saffron camp or the liberal/secular one.” The Acorn asks “Why doesn’t Karan Thapar dare to call anti-Hindutva by its name?” and points out that “neither Sonia Gandhi, nor the Left nor any of the regional parties are truly secular. And they are far from being “liberal”.” The Acorn is right on the money.

The English language media is fairly pathetic. Many of the columnists like Thapar are bhade kay tattoo, eagerly carrying water for the establishment. But there are surprising exceptions. Take Swapan Dasgupta’s column in the Times of India of 30th Dec titled “The Modi Charishma“. A Bong last name like “Dasgupta” to me usually signals extreme prejudice — commies generally. Dasgupta is a welcome exception. He ends his piece with

The Gujarat model is not in conflict with the Bharat model. What has clicked in Gujarat is a leadership style built on innovation, dedication and a resolute defiance of a compromised Establishment. A Modi folklore has been created around an Angry Middle-aged Man with a 56-inch chest.

It has corresponded with subliminal perceptions of good leadership. And the Gujarat voter is no different from the Indian voter.

Modi has aroused great expectations. His political opponents will want him to be confined to Gujarat forever; the Establishment wouldn’t mind him in Race Course Road as long as he removes some of his vital organs surgically.

Let’s hope Modi stays the course. Let’s hope he injects politics with a dose of freshness.

Amen.

  • http://jihadwatch.org/ Notsure

    I understand why Mody was elected.
    Chody’s like thapar on the “other” side of a “dichotomy” do increase the amount of voter a Mody may get but I still am “Notsure” if being anti-islamist alone is a qualification.
    But on the other hand Gujrat did well w/o him and would do well even if they had to reign him.

  • Vaidehi

    Swapan Dasgupta ( also good are Chandan Mitra , Kanchan Gupta all Bengalis :) ) has been consistently good endowed with lateral thinking. His columns in New Indian Express too are a must read. Very original.

  • chakravarty

    Ironically, the only pro-Hindu newspaper in India is bong dominated.

  • http://www.orkut.com/Profile.aspx?uid=14303366728379237878 shanthakumar.s

    Need of The Hour : Hindu Unity

    All Hindus in India should unite to fight for our rights…

    [rest of the comment edited]

  • anuj

    chakravarty – which newspaper are you alluding to?

  • Vaidehi

    anuj ,

    I suppose the newspaper alluded to must be

    ‘ The Pioneer ‘
    http://www.dailypioneer.com.

    It is definitely a non pc quality newspaper coming up with excellent editorials and pertinent news reports. Has a panel of good columnists . In addition to the above mentioned KPS Gill , Ashok Malik and so on. Its quality of English helps in honing one’s communication skills too.